The formal demonstration of the legimaticy of the categories in the Trascendental Deduction (Edition B)

  • Carlos Másmela Arroyave
Keywords: Kant, Transcendental Deduction, pure concepts of understanding


The most important and most widely discussed intetpretation of Kant in recent years has been "Die Beweisstruktur von Kants transzendentaler Deduktion", by Dieter Henrich,
appearing in PRAUSS, Gerold. Hrsg.; Kant. Zur Deutung seiner Theorie von Erkennen und Handeln. Köln, 1973, p. 90-104. Considered from a juridical point of view, deduction gives a proof of the origin of pure knowledge and shows the scope and limits of its pretensions to
legitimacy. Transcendental deduction sets as its goal demonstrating that there
is an irrestricted use of the categories in determining a given multiplicity. Henrich concentrates on the proof of the validity of the pure concepts of understanding and its consequent application. The innovation, according to Henrich, consists in talking, not
about two proofs -as it has been traditional- but only about one proof having two steps, placed in different passages of the second redaction (B). The first one exposes the restriction of validity (15 - 21) whereas the second one refers to the overcoming of this  restriction (26). The first passage shows that all intuitions having unity are under
tbe domain of the categories (20). But something essential in the first part of deduction B is still missing for its complete fulfillment. The restriction is overcome in 26, with the thesis of the unity of the formal intuitions of space and time.

The present article attempts a detailed analysis of the two steps in the proof proposed in Henrich's reconstruction, in order to question the suppositions under which the proof of
legitimacy can go into effect, together with the ulterior application of the pure concepts of understanding

= 16 veces | PDF (ESPAÑOL (ESPAÑA))
= 6 veces|


Download data is not yet available.
How to Cite
Másmela Arroyave, C. (2019). The formal demonstration of the legimaticy of the categories in the Trascendental Deduction (Edition B). Estudios De Filosofía, (1), 9-25. Retrieved from
Original or Research articles