The access to differential justice the situation of the population in a vulnerable situation at cali.

Authors

  • Diana Patricia Quintero M. Universidad Icesi
  • Gabriela Recalde C. Universidad Icesi
  • Juan Fernando Urriago G. Universidad Icesi

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17533/udea.esde.18410

Keywords:

justice access, justice administration, differential approach, judicial oversight, vulnerable groups, legal practitioners representing

Abstract

International and Colombian case law have set the content of the right to access to judicial systems in a constitutional state of law such as Colombia. This content includes the due process of law and the guarantee of equal access to an independent tribunal or court without obstacles based on discriminatory practices that might extend the legal process beyond a reasonable term. As part of its task of defending the rights of vulnerable populations, the Human Rights Clinic of the Universidad Icesi, GAPI,worked on a case of a group of legal practitioners representing a poor population that faced discrimination against in their access to local judicial authorities. The GAPI established vigilance on the local judicial system in order to determine both structural and subjective causes of the discriminatory practices. This vigilance was undertaken in accordance with the provisions of the Law 850 of 2003. In doing so the clinic designed the instruments for collecting information, which allowed us to undertake exploratory research about the way that cultural factors—including practices, beliefs and values—become barriers to the proper functioning of the judicial system. This article shows the results of this case and describes the cultural factors that make access to judiciary system difficult for clients, making it slower and untrustworthy. Based on these findings, the authors make recommendations intended to rectify the identified problem.

|Abstract
= 700 veces | PDF (ESPAÑOL (ESPAÑA))
= 318 veces|

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Diana Patricia Quintero M., Universidad Icesi

Lawyer from the Free University of Cali. Master in Philosophy from the Universidad del Valle. Doctor of Law from the Universidad Externado de Colombia, outstanding Cum laude. She is the author of the book Health as a right. Comparative study on vulnerable groups, Siglo del hombre Editores and Universidad Icesi, Bogotá D.C., 2011. Director of the Icesi Public Actions Group (GAPI) between 2008 and 2012 and the oversight project. She is currently a Hubert H. Humphrey fellow at the University of Minnesota School of Law, United States, within the framework of the Fulbright Colombia scholarship program.

Gabriela Recalde C., Universidad Icesi

Lawyer from the Icesi University. She is a specialist in Culture of Peace and International Humanitarian Law from the Pontificia Universidad Javeriana-Cali. Currently, she coordinates the Public Actions Group of the Icesi University. She is a research assistant on the project.

Juan Fernando Urriago G., Universidad Icesi

Lawyer from the Icesi University. Associate researcher and lecturer at the Faculty of Law and Social Sciences of the same University. Project coordinator.

References

Acosta Alvarado, P.A. (2007). El derecho de acceso a la justicia en la jurisprudencia interamericana. Bogotá: Colección Temas de derecho Público No. 77., pp. 43

Argemiro, A. (2009). Herramientas para la formulación y negociación del presupuesto público en el sector justicia colombiano 1993 – 2008. Bogotá.

Cesar, J., Cifuentes, A. y Solano, J.A. (2003). Nuevas evidencias de la crisis caleña. Revista Estudios Gerenciales, Universidad Icesi, 089, 43-55.

Birgin, H. y Kohen, B. (2006). El Acceso a la Justicia como derecho. En Acceso a la justicia como garantía de igualdad. Instituciones, actores y experiencias comparadas. (15 y ss) Buenos Aires: Biblos.

Buendía García, P. (2010). Presupuesto de inversión en Colombia: Sector Justicia. En IV Seminario de Gestión Judicial. La inversión en justicia. (151 y ss). Chile: CEJA.

Bustamente, A. y Cabezón, A. (2009). Reporte de la Justicia, Cuarta edición 2008- 2009. Chile: CEJA. Disponible en: www.ceja.cl/

Cáceres Tovar, V.M., Chacón Triana, N.M., Gómez Carmona, W. y Huertas Díaz, O. (2005). Convención Americana de Derechos Humanos. Doctrina y Jurisprudencia. 1980 – 2005. Bogotá: Grupo Editorial IBAÑEZ.

Cerrillo, A. (2007). Las tecnologías de la información y el conocimiento al servicio de la justicia iberoamericana en el siglo XXI. E-Justicia (monográfico en línea), IPD, Revista de Internet, Derecho y Política. Universitat de Oberta de Catalunya. Chamorro, B.F. (1994). La tutela judicial efectiva. Barcelona: Casa editorial.

República de Colombia. Ministerio de Hacienda (2006). Marco de Gasto de Mediano Plazo 2007-2010. Colombia

Secretaría Corte Interamericana Derechos Humanos. (2010). Documentos básicos en materia de Derechos Humanos en el Sistema Interamericano. San José de Costa Rica: Editorial Corte Interamericana Derechos Humanos. Notas de prensa

Murcia, L. (2008). “Atentado al Palacio de Justicia de Cali”. Revista Semana .

Urrego R., (2012, Junio 22). “Reforma a la Justicia: el paso a paso de una irresponsabilidad”. Revista Semana.

Published

2012-06-01

How to Cite

Quintero M., D. P., Recalde C., G., & Urriago G., J. F. (2012). The access to differential justice the situation of the population in a vulnerable situation at cali. Estudios De Derecho, 69(154), 73–97. https://doi.org/10.17533/udea.esde.18410