Immunity to error through misidentification and the functionalist, self-reflexive account of episodic memory


  • Steven James West Chester University



immunity to error through misidentification, memory judgments, episodic memory, self-awareness, metaphysics of memory


Fernández (2019) offers an account of the nature of episodic memory that marries two core ideas: (i) role-functionalism about episodic memory, and (ii) self-reflexive mnemonic content. One payoff of this view is that episodic memory judgments are immune to error through misidentification. Fernández takes this to reveal something important about the nature of one’s self-awareness in memory and our first-person conception of ourselves. However, once one sees why such judgments are immune in this way, according to the proposed account, the fact that they are immune becomes moot. While technically immune to error through misidentification, episodic memory judgments are not grounded in a way such that they have any interesting epistemological import for the subject (in contrast to other paradigms of such judgments), and any insights about our self-awareness and self-conception are directly derivable from the metaphysics of memory content alone.

= 1481 veces | PDF
= 18 veces| | HTML
= 11 veces|


Download data is not yet available.


Metrics Loading ...

Author Biography

Steven James, West Chester University

Is associate professor at the West Chester University of Pennsylvania. His specializations are analytic epistemology, philosophy of mind, cognitive science, and philosophy of language. He is currently completing a book-length project on the nature of remembering things.


Behan, D. (1979). Locke on persons and personal identity. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 9, 53–75.

Bermúdez, J. L. (2012). Memory judgments and immunity to error through misidentification. Grazer Philosphische Studien, 84(1), 123-142.

Bermúdez, J. L. (2013). Immunity to error through misidentification and past-tense memory judgments. Analysis, 73(2), 211-220.

Brown, A. S., Croft Caderao, K., Fields, L. M. & Marsh, E. J. (2015). Borrowing personal memories. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 29(3), 471-477.

Cappelen, H. & Dever, J. (2013). The inessential indexical: on the philosophical insignificance of perspective and the first person. Oxford University Press.

Evans, G. (1982). The varieties of reference. Oxford University Press.

Fernández, J. (2006). The intentionality of memory. Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 84, 39-57.

Fernández, J. (2014). Memory and immunity to error through misidentification. Review of Philosophy and Psychology, 5, 373-390.

Fernández, J. (2019) Memory: a self-referential account. Oxford University Press.

Grice, H. P. (1941). Personal identity. Mind, 50, 330-350.

Hamilton, A. (2007). Memory and self-consciousness: immunity to error through misidentification. Synthese, 171, 409-471.

Higginbotham, J. (2010) On words and thoughts about oneself. In F. Recanati, I. Stojanovic & N. Villaneuva (Eds.), Context-dependence, perspective, and relativity (pp. 253-282). De Gruyter Mouton.

Horgan, T. & Kriegel, U. (2007). Phenomenal epistemology: what is consciousness that we may know it so well?. Philosophical Issues, 17, 123-144.

Ismael, J. (2012). Immunity to error as an artefact of transition between representational media. In S. Prosser & F. Recanati (Eds.), Immunity to error through misidentification: new essays. Cambridge University Press.

Levine, J. (2018). Conscious awareness and (self-) representation. In Quality and content: essays on consciousness, representation, and modality. Oxford University Press.

McCarroll, C. (2018). Remembering from the outside: personal memory and the perspectival mind. Oxford University Press.

Merlo, G. (2017). Three questions about immunity to error through misidentification, Erkenntnis, 82, 603-623.

Michaelian, K. (2020). Episodic memory is not immune to error through misidentification: against Fernández. Synthese.

Millar, A. (1991). Reasons and experiences. Clarendon.

Olson, E. T. (2019). Personal identity. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2021 Edition),

Parfit, D. (1984) Reasons and persons. Clarendon.

Pasupathi, M. & Wainryb, C. (2018). Remembering good and bad times together: functions of collaborative remembering. In M. Meade, C. Harris, P. Van Bergen, J. Sutton & A. Barnier (Eds.), Collaborative remembering: theories, research, and applications. Oxford University Press.

Pillemer, D. B., Steiner, K. L., Kuwabara, K. J., Thomsen, D. K. & Svob, C. (2015). Vicarious memories. Consciousness and cognition, 36, 233-245.

Prosser, (2012). Sources of immunity to error through misidentification. In S. Prosser and F. Recanati (Eds.), Immunity to error through misidentification: new essays. Cambridge University Press.

Pryor, J. (1999). Immunity to error through misidentification. Philosophical Topics, 26, 271-304.

Recanati, F. (2007). Perspectival thought: a plea for (moderate) relativism. Oxford University Press.

Reese, E. & Brown, N. (2000). Reminiscing and recounting in the preschool years. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 14. 1-17.<1::AID-ACP625>3.0.CO;2-G

Ross, L. & Ward, A. (1996). Naïve realism: implications for social conflict and misunderstanding. In T. Brown, E. Reed & E. Turiel (Eds.), Values and Knowledge (pp. 103-35). Lawrence Erlbaum.

Schacter, D. L., & Addis, D. R. (2007). The cognitive neuroscience of constructive memory: remembering the past and imagining the future. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 262, 773–786.

Sheen, M., Kemp, S. & Rubin, D. (2001). Twins dispute memory ownership: a new false memory phenomenon. Memory & Cognition, 29(6), 779-788.

Shoemaker, S. (1959). Personal identity and memory. The Journal of Philosophy, 56(22), 868-882.

Shoemaker, S. (1968). Self-reference and self-awareness. Journal of Philosophy, 65, 555-567.

Shoemaker, S. (1970). Persons and their pasts. American Philosophical Quarterly, 7, 269-285.

Soteriou, M. (2000). The particularity of visual perception. European Journal of Philosophy, 8, 173-189.

Tye, M. (2009). Consciousness revisited: materialism without phenomenal concepts. MIT Press.

Wittgenstein, L. (1958). The blue and brown books. Blackwell.




How to Cite

James, S. (2021). Immunity to error through misidentification and the functionalist, self-reflexive account of episodic memory. Estudios De Filosofía, (64), 189–200.

Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.